Insurance Defense

Experienced, Comprehensive Representation

The litigation practice is O'Donnell, McCoy & Heleniak's cornerstone providing legal services to insurers and their policy holders.  Our extensive experience is in all aspects of trial practice from alternative dispute resolution to trial by jury. 

The firm is experienced in handling litigation stemming from

  • auto negligence

  • premises liability

  • commercial liability 

  • fraudulent insurance claims

  • homeowners claims

  • declaratory judgment actions

  • workers compensation claims

  • subrogation claims

  • Title 59 actions against municipal entities


O'Donnell McCoy Heleniak specializes in providing quality insurance defense litigation support, representing insureds and insurance companies, municipal entities, large corporations and small businesses throughout New Jersey.  We work closely with in-house counsel, claims administrators, third party administrators, corporate officers and individuals.  With decades of insurance defense experience,  we understand the complicated legal issues at play and can economize the resources at stake.  The firm is committed to providing high quality work and exceptional responsiveness to clients in an increasingly cost-sensitive environment. 

Our attorneys use innovative strategies and thorough preparation to achieve our clients' objectives in the most efficient and cost-effective manner possible. We are proud of our ability to take cases to trial when necessary to defend clients’ rights, though we often succed in obtaining favorable results through negotiated settlements.  We have a strong track record of success defending the interests of our clients before state and federal courts at both the trial and appellate levels. 


Contact Us

To schedule a consultation with one of our experienced lawyers, contact our office in Morristown at 973-998-9800.  Prospective clients may also contact us online.